Comparison

Types of goal tracking tool, compared.

Six kinds of tool all call themselves goal tracking; they solve very different problems, so it helps to know which one you’re actually shopping for.

When a founder or COO goes looking for a goal tracking tool, the first surprise is how many different things turn up under the same name. A habit app, an OKR platform, a project board with a goals tab, an HR system with quarterly reviews and a meeting tool built around a methodology all describe themselves as goal tracking, and on a feature list they can look almost identical, because they all let you write a goal down and mark how far along it is.

The difference is in what each kind of tool thinks a goal is for, and that decides what it’s good at. So before comparing products, it’s worth working out which type you need; I’ve set out the six I see most often below, with what each one is built to do and where it tends to fall short for a leadership team.

The six types of goal tracking tool

1. Spreadsheets and documents

Almost every company starts here, with a strategy doc from the offsite and a spreadsheet that someone updates before the board meeting. It’s free, flexible and everyone already knows how to use it, which is exactly why it lasts longer than it should; the trouble is that a spreadsheet only knows what someone typed into it last, so the picture is out of date for most of the month and the reasons behind each number live in people’s heads. I’ve written more about this in goal tracking tool vs spreadsheet.

2. Project management tools

Asana, Monday, ClickUp, Jira, Linear and Notion are brilliant at tracking work: tasks, owners, dates and dependencies. Many of them have added a goals feature, which usually rolls task completion up into a percentage, and that’s where the problem starts, because a goal can be 90% of its tasks done and still nowhere near achieved. They answer “is the work getting done?” rather than “is the work moving the goal?”, which I’ve compared in goal tracking tool vs project management tool.

3. OKR software

Tools such as Perdoo, Tability, Quantive and Profit.co are built around objectives and key results: you write an objective, add three to five measurable key results, link them across teams and score them each quarter. They’re well suited to larger companies with many teams to coordinate, and the cascading and scoring is genuinely useful there; in smaller companies the ritual can become heavier than the work, and a key result turning red still doesn’t tell you why.

4. Performance management platforms

Lattice, Leapsome, 15Five and Culture Amp include goals as part of reviews, one-to-ones and engagement surveys. They’re good at individual development and at linking a person’s goals to the company’s, but because the goals feed performance reviews, people tend to set them safely and report them carefully, and the company goal gets lost in a tree of individual targets.

5. Business operating system tools

Ninety, Bloom Growth and similar tools are built to run a specific operating system, usually EOS, with rocks, scorecards, issues lists and a weekly meeting agenda. If you’ve committed to that system they keep it running well, and the weekly rhythm is the most valuable part; the cost is that the tool assumes the methodology, so you take the whole system or very little of it.

6. Constraint-led goal tracking tools

This is the newest type, and it’s the one Clearahead belongs to. A constraint-led tool tracks each goal alongside a short, ordered list of what’s holding it back and the moves that will clear it, so when a goal slips you can see which constraint is stuck and who owns it rather than just a red dot. It comes from Goldratt’s Theory of Constraints, which I’ve covered in the five focusing steps, and it’s built for leadership teams whose goals are clear but keep slipping.

The six types of goal tracking tool side by side
TypeBuilt to answerGood atFalls short whenTypical buyer
Spreadsheets and docsWhat did we say we’d do?Free, flexible, familiarMore than a handful of people need a current pictureVery early teams
Project management toolsIs the work getting done?Tasks, owners, dates and dependenciesYou need to know whether the work is moving the goalOperations and delivery teams
OKR softwareDid we hit our key results?Cascading and scoring goals across many teamsA key result goes red and nobody knows whyCompanies of a few hundred people and up
Performance managementHow is each person doing?Reviews, one-to-ones and developmentGoals are set safely because they feed reviewsHR and people teams
Operating system toolsAre we running the system?A weekly meeting rhythm and accountabilityYou don’t want the whole methodologyTeams committed to EOS or similar
Constraint-led toolsWhat’s holding the goal back?Alignment on the goal, its constraints and the movesYou need individual reviews or detailed scoringLeadership teams of growing companies

Which type should you choose?

The honest answer is that most companies end up with more than one, and that’s fine as long as each does its own job. Keep the project tool for the doing and the HR platform for reviews, because they’re good at those things; the question is which tool holds the company’s goals, the one place the leadership team looks to decide what matters this week.

For that job, I’d ask three questions. First, how many teams do you need to coordinate? If it’s dozens, OKR software earns its keep, and if it’s a handful, it’s probably more than you need. Second, have you committed to a methodology? If you run EOS properly, the tool built for it will serve you well, and if you haven’t, don’t buy a methodology by accident. Third, when a goal slips, do you know why? If the answer is usually “not really”, you need a tool that tracks what’s in the way and not just the score, which is the gap constraint-led tools were built to fill.

If you want to go further, I’ve written a checklist for choosing a goal tracking tool, and the full goal tracking tool guide covers the methods, pitfalls and roll-out in one place.

Questions

What are the main types of goal tracking tool?

Spreadsheets and documents, project management tools, OKR software, performance management platforms, business operating system tools and constraint-led goal tracking tools. Each is built to answer a different question, from “is the work done?” to “what’s holding the goal back?”.

Is OKR software the same as a goal tracking tool?

OKR software is one type of goal tracking tool, built around objectives and key results scored every quarter. Other goal tracking tools don’t use OKRs at all and organise goals around owners, rocks or the constraints in the way.

Can a project management tool track company goals?

Many can link tasks to a goal and show a percentage complete, which is useful for delivery. It doesn’t show whether the work is moving the goal, so most leadership teams keep company goals somewhere else and the doing in the project tool.

Which type of goal tracking tool is best for a small company?

For a company under about 200 people with a handful of teams, a lighter tool usually works better than full OKR software: one or two company goals everyone can remember, what’s holding each one back and a weekly rhythm to clear it.

The complete guide to goal tracking tools.

What a good goal tracking tool does, the types and methods compared, the pitfalls, how to choose one and how to roll it out, all in one place.

Read the goal tracking tool guide

Track the goal, and what’s in its way.

Free for up to 3 people. No card needed.

See how Clearahead keeps leadership teams aligned