Comparison

Goal tracking tool vs spreadsheet: when to make the switch.

A spreadsheet is the right first goal tracking tool for most companies; the skill is noticing the moment it quietly stops being one.

I’ll start by defending the spreadsheet, because it gets a hard time from people who sell software, me included. A spreadsheet is free, everyone can use it, it bends to whatever shape your goals take and it doesn’t ask you to learn a methodology first, which is exactly what a team of five founders and early hires needs in its first year.

The problem isn’t that spreadsheets are bad at goal tracking; it’s that they’re good enough for long enough that companies keep using them well past the point where they work, and the cost of that is invisible until the leadership team realises it hasn’t been looking at the same picture for months.

What a spreadsheet does well

  • It’s flexible. You can track a revenue number, a launch date and a hiring target side by side, in whatever format suits each one.
  • It’s free and familiar. There’s nothing to buy, nothing to roll out and nobody to train.
  • It’s honest about what it is. Nobody mistakes a spreadsheet for a system, so nobody expects it to do more than hold the numbers.

Five signs your spreadsheet has stopped working

  1. 01

    It’s only current the day before a meeting.

    Someone updates it before the board meeting or the monthly review, so for most of the month the leadership team is looking at old numbers, or not looking at all.

  2. 02

    The why lives in people’s heads.

    The cells say a goal is behind, but the reason, what’s been tried and who’s on it are in Slack threads and memory, so every review starts with the same catch-up.

  3. 03

    There are several versions.

    Sales has a copy, finance has a copy and the founder has the one from the offsite, and in the meeting nobody is quite sure whose numbers are right.

  4. 04

    Nobody outside the leadership team opens it.

    The people doing the work can’t see how it connects to the goal, so they optimise for their own team’s targets instead.

  5. 05

    Updating it is somebody’s job.

    When one person spends hours a month chasing numbers and rebuilding the board pack, the spreadsheet has become a cost rather than a tool.

A spreadsheet and a goal tracking tool, side by side
SpreadsheetGoal tracking tool
CostFreeFree plans exist; paid plans for the whole company
Set-upMinutes, from a blank sheetAn afternoon, with structure built in
Stays currentOnly when someone updates itWhen people update in a sentence as the work moves
Explains whyNot unless someone writes a commentHolds what’s in the way, who owns it and what’s been tried
One version of the truthRarely, once it’s copiedYes, for everyone with access
Board and investor updatesRebuilt by hand each monthViewers read the current picture any time
Best forVery early teams of a few peopleLeadership teams with several people owning parts of the goal

What a goal tracking tool adds

The thing a goal tracking tool adds isn’t more columns; it’s a shared structure and a way of staying current that doesn’t depend on one person. In Clearahead, for example, each goal has its own page with what you’re aiming for, why it matters and how you’ll know, and under it sits an ordered list of what’s holding it back and the moves to clear each constraint, every one with an owner. People update in a sentence when the work moves, the evidence is kept, and the leadership team gets a weekly summary of what changed and what needs a decision.

That last part is what replaces the monthly scramble. Instead of someone rebuilding the picture before the meeting, the picture is already there, and the meeting becomes a conversation about the one or two things that need the leadership team, which is the reason you track goals in the first place.

Making the switch without losing anything

Don’t try to move every row across. Pick the one or two goals that matter most this year, write them up properly in the new tool, and leave the rest of the spreadsheet where it is for reference; most of what’s in a goals spreadsheet after a year is history rather than direction. Then ask the people who own each part of the goal to update it in the new tool for a month, and see whether the weekly meeting changes. I’ve written a fuller guide to rolling out a goal tracking tool, and there’s a direct comparison in spreadsheets vs Clearahead.

If you’re not sure you’re ready, that’s fine too; start with a free goal tracking tool, which costs nothing more than the spreadsheet did and tells you quickly whether the structure helps.

Questions

Can I track company goals in a spreadsheet?

Yes, and most companies start that way. It works while a few people own the goals and update them together; it tends to break once more people need a current picture than keep it up to date.

When should we move from a spreadsheet to a goal tracking tool?

When the spreadsheet is only current before meetings, when there are several versions, when the reasons behind the numbers live in people’s heads, or when someone spends hours a month updating it. Two or more of those usually means it’s time.

Is there a free alternative to a goals spreadsheet?

Yes. Clearahead has a free plan for up to three people and one workspace with no card needed, which is enough for a founding team to track its main goal and what’s holding it back.

The complete guide to goal tracking tools.

What a good goal tracking tool does, the types and methods compared, the pitfalls, how to choose one and how to roll it out, all in one place.

Read the goal tracking tool guide

Move the goal out of the spreadsheet and into the team.

Free for up to 3 people. No card needed.

See how Clearahead keeps leadership teams aligned