Pitfalls

Eight goal tracking pitfalls, and how to avoid them.

Most goal tracking doesn’t fail because of the tool; it fails in a handful of predictable ways that are much easier to avoid than to fix later.

I’ve watched a lot of companies roll out goal tracking, and most of them end up in the same place six months later: a tool full of goals that were set carefully in January, updated enthusiastically in February and quietly abandoned by April, with the leadership team back to arguing about the picture in the weekly meeting. It’s rarely the tool’s fault, and it’s almost never because the team didn’t care; it’s because goal tracking fails in a handful of predictable ways, and each one is easy to fall into.

Here are the eight I see most often, with what each looks like and what to do instead.

The eight pitfalls

  1. 01

    Too many goals.

    Every department adds three, the company adds five, and suddenly there are forty goals and no priorities. Fix: one or two company goals that everyone can name, with everything else serving them.

  2. 02

    Tracking activity, not outcomes.

    The goal shows 80% because 80% of the tasks are done, but the result hasn’t moved. Fix: track how close you are to the outcome, and keep the tasks in the project tool.

  3. 03

    Check-ins that go stale.

    Updates happen the day before the review, so the picture is out of date for most of the quarter. Fix: make updating take a sentence, as the work moves, rather than a form before a meeting.

  4. 04

    Company goals tied to reviews.

    When goals feed pay and promotion, people set them safely and report them carefully. Fix: keep company goals separate from individual performance, so people can be honest about what’s in the way.

  5. 05

    Goals in five places.

    The offsite deck, the board spreadsheet, the OKR tool and the HR platform all disagree. Fix: one place for the company’s goals, which everything else points to.

  6. 06

    Red with no reason.

    A goal turns red and nobody can say what’s actually in the way, or who’s fixing it. Fix: track the constraints holding each goal back, each with an owner, alongside the score.

  7. 07

    Goals nobody can remember.

    A goal that needs a baseline, a number, a date and a method to be accurate is one most people can’t repeat. Fix: one memorable line, with the precision in the measure underneath.

  8. 08

    Never changing course.

    The plan from the offsite is treated as fixed, so the team keeps working on moves that have stopped mattering. Fix: keep the goal steady and let the moves change as constraints clear.

The common thread

Look at those eight together and most of them come from the same mistake, which is treating goal tracking as a reporting job rather than a thinking job. If the point of the tool is to produce a status for the next meeting, people will update it just before the meeting, set goals they can safely report and add more goals whenever someone wants their work to be visible; if the point is to help the leadership team decide what to do next, the tool needs to show what’s holding each goal back, stay current between meetings and stay small enough that everyone can hold it in their head.

How to avoid them from the start

  • Start with one goal. Get one company goal working well, with its constraints and moves and a weekly rhythm, before you add a second.
  • Put the why next to the score. For every goal, write down what’s holding it back, in order, and give the top constraint an owner and a few moves.
  • Make updating effortless. If updating takes more than a sentence, it won’t happen between meetings. Choose a tool that keeps the evidence for you.
  • Keep reviews separate. Use your HR platform for individual development, and keep company goals somewhere people can be candid.
  • Review weekly, briefly. Thirty minutes on what moved, what’s stuck and what needs a decision does more than a long quarterly review. My guide to running a weekly leadership meeting sets out an agenda.

If you’re choosing a tool, these pitfalls make a good test: ask each vendor how their tool prevents them, and see who has a real answer. The checklist for choosing a goal tracking tool turns them into questions, and the goal tracking tool guide puts it all together.

Questions

Why does goal tracking fail?

Usually because it becomes a reporting job: too many goals, check-ins done just before meetings, goals tied to reviews so they’re set safely, and red statuses with no explanation. It works when it stays small, current and focused on what’s holding each goal back.

How many company goals should we track?

For most companies under about 200 people, one or two company goals that everyone can name, with department work serving them. More than that and the goals stop being priorities.

Should company goals be linked to performance reviews?

It’s usually better to keep them separate. When company goals feed pay and promotion, people set them safely and report them carefully, and the leadership team loses the honest picture of what’s in the way.

How often should we review goals?

Weekly and briefly works best: what moved, what’s stuck and what needs a decision. A longer review every quarter is useful too, but it can’t replace the weekly rhythm.

The complete guide to goal tracking tools.

What a good goal tracking tool does, the types and methods compared, the pitfalls, how to choose one and how to roll it out, all in one place.

Read the goal tracking tool guide

Fewer goals, a clear view of what’s in the way.

Free for up to 3 people. No card needed.

See how Clearahead keeps leadership teams aligned