Most goal tracking tools look good in a demo, because a demo shows a tidy company with ten well-written goals, a handful of happy owners and a dashboard full of green. The question isn’t whether the tool looks good with perfect data; it’s whether it will still be used, and still be current, three months after you roll it out to a busy team with messy goals.
So before you look at features, answer three questions, then use the checklist below on your shortlist.
Three questions to answer first
1. What job does the tool need to do?
Be specific. “Coordinate goals across twenty teams and score them each quarter” points you to OKR software; “run EOS properly” points you to the tool built for it; “keep our leadership team aligned on a few big goals and what’s in the way” points you to something lighter. Most disappointment comes from buying a tool built for a different job, which is why it helps to know the types of goal tracking tool first.
2. Who will update it, and who will read it?
Write down the names. If the people who update it are busy heads of department, updating has to take seconds or it won’t happen; if the readers include the board and investors, they need a view that doesn’t require training or a seat licence.
3. What method will you use?
Every tool assumes a method, whether that’s OKRs, rocks or constraints. Choose the method first, because the tool will push you towards its own; my guide to common goal tracking methods compares them.
The checklist
What a good goal tracking tool should do
- Hold a small number of company goals, each with what you’re aiming for, why it matters and how you’ll know.
- Show what’s holding each goal back, in order, with an owner for each constraint.
- Track the handful of moves that matter, without turning into a task manager.
- Let people update in seconds, in their own words, as the work moves.
- Keep the evidence behind every update, so you can see what changed and why.
- Give the leadership team one current picture, with a weekly summary of what needs a decision.
- Let the board, investors and advisers follow along without paying per seat.
- Work alongside the project, HR and reporting tools you already use, rather than replacing them.
- Let you change course without rewriting the whole plan.
- Be free to try with your real goals, with no card and no sales call needed.
Features that matter less than they look
Some features sell well and change very little. Elaborate dashboards with dozens of charts tend to be looked at in the demo and ignored afterwards; deep goal trees with five levels of cascading are impressive but mostly create work in a company of under a couple of hundred people; and hundreds of integrations are useful only if the integration answers a question you actually have. None of these are bad, but none of them will fix a leadership team that isn’t aligned, so don’t let them decide the purchase.
Questions to ask in a demo or trial
- “Show me what happens when a goal goes off track. Where do I see why?”
- “How long does an update take, and what does the person updating actually do?”
- “What does our board see, and what does it cost to add them?”
- “What happens when we change our mind about a priority halfway through a quarter?”
- “How do teams that stop using your tool usually stop?”
The last question is the most revealing, and a good vendor will answer it honestly. If you’ve read the goal tracking pitfalls, you can also ask how the tool prevents each one.
Trial it properly
The best test of a goal tracking tool is a month with one real goal. Set it up with the people who actually own the work, update it as things happen rather than before meetings, and run your weekly leadership meeting from it; if the meeting gets shorter and the conversation moves from “where are we?” to “what should we do?”, the tool is working. Clearahead’s free plan is designed for exactly that, with up to three people and one workspace and no card needed, and the goal tracking tool guide covers the rest.
Questions
What should I look for in a goal tracking tool?
A small number of clear goals, a view of what’s holding each one back, updates that take seconds, one current picture for the whole leadership team, free access for the board and investors, and a free trial you can run with real goals.
How long should a goal tracking tool trial be?
Long enough to run four weekly leadership meetings from it, so about a month. That shows whether people keep it current between meetings, which a short demo never will.
Do we need OKR software?
Only if you need to coordinate and score goals across many teams. Most companies under about 200 people do better with a lighter tool built around a few company goals and what’s holding them back.
How much does a goal tracking tool cost?
Prices range from free plans to per-seat pricing that grows with the team. Clearahead is free for up to three people, then £297 a month or £2,997 a year for the whole company, with unlimited people and no seats to count.